WEBVTT
Kind: captions
Language: en

00:00:01.719 --> 00:00:03.582 align:start position:0%
 
The<00:00:01.926><c> new</c><00:00:02.133><c> boy</c><00:00:02.340><c> group</c><00:00:02.650><c> made</c><00:00:02.909><c> by</c><00:00:03.064><c> artificial</c>

00:00:03.582 --> 00:00:03.634 align:start position:0%
The new boy group made by artificial
 

00:00:03.634 --> 00:00:05.549 align:start position:0%
The new boy group made by artificial
 intelligence<00:00:04.307><c> that</c><00:00:04.566><c> everyone</c><00:00:05.031><c> is</c><00:00:05.187><c> calling</c>

00:00:05.549 --> 00:00:05.601 align:start position:0%
 intelligence that everyone is calling
 

00:00:05.601 --> 00:00:07.257 align:start position:0%
 intelligence that everyone is calling
 to<00:00:05.756><c> be</c><00:00:05.911><c> disbanded</c><00:00:06.377><c>,</c><00:00:06.481><c> or</c><00:00:06.636><c> so</c><00:00:06.791><c> it</c><00:00:06.947><c> seems</c><00:00:07.206><c>,</c>

00:00:07.257 --> 00:00:07.309 align:start position:0%
 to be disbanded, or so it seems,
 

00:00:07.309 --> 00:00:09.276 align:start position:0%
 to be disbanded, or so it seems,
 because<00:00:07.723><c> the</c><00:00:07.930><c> group</c><00:00:08.241><c> keeps</c><00:00:08.551><c> increasing</c><00:00:09.121><c> its</c>

00:00:09.276 --> 00:00:09.328 align:start position:0%
 because the group keeps increasing its
 

00:00:09.328 --> 00:00:13.741 align:start position:0%
 because the group keeps increasing its
 followers<00:00:09.846><c> on</c><00:00:10.001><c> Instagram</c><00:00:10.467><c>.</c><00:00:12.759><c> MUO</c><00:00:13.021><c> is</c><00:00:13.217><c> sparking</c>

00:00:13.741 --> 00:00:13.807 align:start position:0%
 followers on Instagram. MUO is sparking
 

00:00:13.807 --> 00:00:16.296 align:start position:0%
 followers on Instagram. MUO is sparking
 another<00:00:14.331><c> heated</c><00:00:14.789><c> controversy</c><00:00:15.576><c> among</c><00:00:15.969><c> K-pop</c>

00:00:16.296 --> 00:00:16.362 align:start position:0%
 another heated controversy among K-pop
 

00:00:16.362 --> 00:00:18.851 align:start position:0%
 another heated controversy among K-pop
 fans<00:00:16.689><c> after</c><00:00:17.082><c> its</c><00:00:17.344><c> members</c><00:00:17.868><c> were</c><00:00:18.196><c> accused</c><00:00:18.720><c> of</c>

00:00:18.851 --> 00:00:18.917 align:start position:0%
 fans after its members were accused of
 

00:00:18.917 --> 00:00:23.368 align:start position:0%
 fans after its members were accused of
 looking<00:00:19.441><c> too</c><00:00:19.703><c> much</c><00:00:20.030><c> like</c><00:00:20.358><c> real</c><00:00:20.685><c> idols</c><00:00:21.013><c>.</c><00:00:23.239><c> On</c>

00:00:23.368 --> 00:00:23.433 align:start position:0%
 looking too much like real idols. On
 

00:00:23.433 --> 00:00:25.899 align:start position:0%
 looking too much like real idols. On
 October<00:00:23.952><c> 14</c><00:00:24.082><c>,</c><00:00:24.212><c> Stone</c><00:00:24.601><c> Music</c><00:00:24.991><c> introduced</c><00:00:25.704><c> the</c>

00:00:25.899 --> 00:00:25.964 align:start position:0%
 October 14, Stone Music introduced the
 

00:00:25.964 --> 00:00:28.495 align:start position:0%
 October 14, Stone Music introduced the
 five-member<00:00:26.743><c> group's</c><00:00:27.262><c> pre-release</c><00:00:28.040><c> single</c><00:00:28.430><c>,</c>

00:00:28.495 --> 00:00:28.559 align:start position:0%
 five-member group's pre-release single,
 

00:00:28.559 --> 00:00:31.025 align:start position:0%
 five-member group's pre-release single,
 but<00:00:28.819><c> attention</c><00:00:29.468><c> quickly</c><00:00:29.987><c> shifted</c><00:00:30.506><c> to</c><00:00:30.701><c> their</c>

00:00:31.025 --> 00:00:31.090 align:start position:0%
 but attention quickly shifted to their
 

00:00:31.090 --> 00:00:35.260 align:start position:0%
 but attention quickly shifted to their
 virtual<00:00:31.609><c> faces</c><00:00:31.934><c>.</c><00:00:34.219><c> On</c><00:00:34.414><c> social</c><00:00:34.869><c> media</c><00:00:35.195><c>,</c>

00:00:35.260 --> 00:00:35.325 align:start position:0%
 virtual faces. On social media,
 

00:00:35.325 --> 00:00:37.537 align:start position:0%
 virtual faces. On social media,
 numerous<00:00:35.910><c> users</c><00:00:36.301><c> began</c><00:00:36.691><c> comparing</c><00:00:37.342><c> the</c>

00:00:37.537 --> 00:00:37.602 align:start position:0%
 numerous users began comparing the
 

00:00:37.602 --> 00:00:39.685 align:start position:0%
 numerous users began comparing the
 appearance<00:00:38.318><c> of</c><00:00:38.513><c> the</c><00:00:38.774><c> MUO</c><00:00:39.034><c> members</c><00:00:39.555><c> to</c>

00:00:39.685 --> 00:00:39.750 align:start position:0%
 appearance of the MUO members to
 

00:00:39.750 --> 00:00:42.223 align:start position:0%
 appearance of the MUO members to
 artists<00:00:40.270><c> already</c><00:00:40.791><c> known</c><00:00:41.181><c> in</c><00:00:41.377><c> the</c><00:00:41.637><c> industry</c><00:00:42.158><c>,</c>

00:00:42.223 --> 00:00:42.288 align:start position:0%
 artists already known in the industry,
 

00:00:42.288 --> 00:00:44.565 align:start position:0%
 artists already known in the industry,
 questioning<00:00:43.069><c> how</c><00:00:43.329><c> the</c><00:00:43.589><c> characters</c><00:00:44.305><c> were</c>

00:00:44.565 --> 00:00:44.630 align:start position:0%
 questioning how the characters were
 

00:00:44.630 --> 00:00:46.648 align:start position:0%
 questioning how the characters were
 designed<00:00:45.216><c> and</c><00:00:45.476><c> why</c><00:00:45.737><c> they</c><00:00:46.062><c> looked</c><00:00:46.518><c> so</c>

00:00:46.648 --> 00:00:46.713 align:start position:0%
 designed and why they looked so
 

00:00:46.713 --> 00:00:51.134 align:start position:0%
 designed and why they looked so
 familiar<00:00:47.233><c>.</c><00:00:48.979><c> Among</c><00:00:49.457><c> the</c><00:00:49.777><c> artists</c><00:00:50.415><c> mentioned</c>

00:00:51.134 --> 00:00:51.214 align:start position:0%
 familiar. Among the artists mentioned
 

00:00:51.214 --> 00:00:54.247 align:start position:0%
 familiar. Among the artists mentioned
 whose<00:00:51.693><c> looks</c><00:00:52.172><c> the</c><00:00:52.491><c> MUO</c><00:00:52.810><c> members</c><00:00:53.449><c> supposedly</c>

00:00:54.247 --> 00:00:54.327 align:start position:0%
 whose looks the MUO members supposedly
 

00:00:54.327 --> 00:00:56.722 align:start position:0%
 whose looks the MUO members supposedly
 stole<00:00:54.806><c> are</c><00:00:55.126><c> names</c><00:00:55.604><c> like</c><00:00:56.004><c> Dohun</c><00:00:56.483><c> and</c>

00:00:56.722 --> 00:00:56.802 align:start position:0%
 stole are names like Dohun and
 

00:00:56.802 --> 00:00:59.516 align:start position:0%
 stole are names like Dohun and
 Young-woo<00:00:57.600><c> from</c><00:00:57.999><c> TWS</c><00:00:58.239><c>,</c><00:00:58.399><c> Zhang</c><00:00:58.878><c> Hao</c><00:00:59.197><c> from</c>

00:00:59.516 --> 00:00:59.596 align:start position:0%
 Young-woo from TWS, Zhang Hao from
 

00:00:59.596 --> 00:01:02.709 align:start position:0%
 Young-woo from TWS, Zhang Hao from
 ZEROBASEONE<00:01:00.474><c>,</c><00:01:00.634><c> and</c><00:01:00.953><c> Sunoo</c><00:01:01.432><c> from</c><00:01:01.831><c> ENHYPEN</c><00:01:02.390><c>,</c><00:01:02.550><c> in</c>

00:01:02.709 --> 00:01:02.789 align:start position:0%
 ZEROBASEONE, and Sunoo from ENHYPEN, in
 

00:01:02.789 --> 00:01:05.663 align:start position:0%
 ZEROBASEONE, and Sunoo from ENHYPEN, in
 addition<00:01:03.508><c> to</c><00:01:03.747><c> general</c><00:01:04.386><c> comparisons</c><00:01:05.344><c> with</c>

00:01:05.663 --> 00:01:05.743 align:start position:0%
 addition to general comparisons with
 

00:01:05.743 --> 00:01:09.685 align:start position:0%
 addition to general comparisons with
 members<00:01:06.382><c> of</c><00:01:06.621><c> TXT</c><00:01:06.941><c> and</c><00:01:07.260><c> ENHYPEN</c><00:01:07.819><c>.</c><00:01:09.104><c> A</c><00:01:09.249><c> visual</c>

00:01:09.685 --> 00:01:09.758 align:start position:0%
 members of TXT and ENHYPEN. A visual
 

00:01:09.758 --> 00:01:12.377 align:start position:0%
 members of TXT and ENHYPEN. A visual
 comparison<00:01:10.558><c> with</c><00:01:10.922><c> soloist</c><00:01:11.504><c> Lee</c><00:01:11.795><c> Hwan-hee</c>

00:01:12.377 --> 00:01:12.450 align:start position:0%
 comparison with soloist Lee Hwan-hee
 

00:01:12.450 --> 00:01:16.533 align:start position:0%
 comparison with soloist Lee Hwan-hee
 also<00:01:12.813><c> circulated</c><00:01:13.541><c>.</c><00:01:15.020><c> For</c><00:01:15.295><c> some</c><00:01:15.639><c> netizens</c><00:01:16.189><c>,</c><00:01:16.327><c> the</c>

00:01:16.533 --> 00:01:16.602 align:start position:0%
 also circulated. For some netizens, the
 

00:01:16.602 --> 00:01:19.147 align:start position:0%
 also circulated. For some netizens, the
 similarities<00:01:17.496><c> are</c><00:01:17.771><c> so</c><00:01:17.978><c> evident</c><00:01:18.528><c> that</c><00:01:18.872><c> they</c>

00:01:19.147 --> 00:01:19.216 align:start position:0%
 similarities are so evident that they
 

00:01:19.216 --> 00:01:21.762 align:start position:0%
 similarities are so evident that they
 claim<00:01:19.629><c> they</c><00:01:19.973><c> can</c><00:01:20.248><c> quickly</c><00:01:20.798><c> identify</c><00:01:21.418><c> which</c>

00:01:21.762 --> 00:01:21.830 align:start position:0%
 claim they can quickly identify which
 

00:01:21.830 --> 00:01:24.513 align:start position:0%
 claim they can quickly identify which
 artists<00:01:22.381><c> the</c><00:01:22.656><c> MUO</c><00:01:22.931><c> members</c><00:01:23.481><c> remind</c><00:01:23.963><c> them</c><00:01:24.307><c> of</c><00:01:24.445><c>,</c>

00:01:24.513 --> 00:01:24.582 align:start position:0%
 artists the MUO members remind them of,
 

00:01:24.582 --> 00:01:27.128 align:start position:0%
 artists the MUO members remind them of,
 fueling<00:01:25.133><c> accusations</c><00:01:25.958><c> that</c><00:01:26.302><c> the</c><00:01:26.577><c> group</c><00:01:26.990><c> is</c>

00:01:27.128 --> 00:01:27.196 align:start position:0%
 fueling accusations that the group is
 

00:01:27.196 --> 00:01:29.811 align:start position:0%
 fueling accusations that the group is
 taking<00:01:27.678><c> advantage</c><00:01:28.366><c> of</c><00:01:28.572><c> the</c><00:01:28.848><c> image</c><00:01:29.260><c> of</c><00:01:29.467><c> idols</c>

00:01:29.811 --> 00:01:29.880 align:start position:0%
 taking advantage of the image of idols
 

00:01:29.880 --> 00:01:32.494 align:start position:0%
 taking advantage of the image of idols
 who<00:01:30.155><c> already</c><00:01:30.705><c> have</c><00:01:31.049><c> a</c><00:01:31.187><c> recognized</c><00:01:31.943><c> identity</c>

00:01:32.494 --> 00:01:32.563 align:start position:0%
 who already have a recognized identity
 

00:01:32.563 --> 00:01:36.614 align:start position:0%
 who already have a recognized identity
 within<00:01:33.044><c> the</c><00:01:33.319><c> industry</c><00:01:33.870><c>.</c><00:01:35.559><c> The</c><00:01:35.822><c> controversy</c><00:01:36.548><c>,</c>

00:01:36.614 --> 00:01:36.680 align:start position:0%
 within the industry. The controversy,
 

00:01:36.680 --> 00:01:38.792 align:start position:0%
 within the industry. The controversy,
 of<00:01:36.878><c> course</c><00:01:37.274><c>,</c><00:01:37.406><c> has</c><00:01:37.670><c> led</c><00:01:37.934><c> some</c><00:01:38.264><c> users</c><00:01:38.660><c> to</c>

00:01:38.792 --> 00:01:38.858 align:start position:0%
 of course, has led some users to
 

00:01:38.858 --> 00:01:41.299 align:start position:0%
 of course, has led some users to
 describe<00:01:39.451><c> the</c><00:01:39.715><c> project</c><00:01:40.243><c> as</c><00:01:40.441><c> an</c><00:01:40.639><c> attempt</c><00:01:41.167><c> to</c>

00:01:41.299 --> 00:01:41.365 align:start position:0%
 describe the project as an attempt to
 

00:01:41.365 --> 00:01:43.674 align:start position:0%
 describe the project as an attempt to
 reproduce<00:01:42.025><c> the</c><00:01:42.289><c> faces</c><00:01:42.684><c> of</c><00:01:42.882><c> real</c><00:01:43.212><c> artists</c>

00:01:43.674 --> 00:01:43.740 align:start position:0%
 reproduce the faces of real artists
 

00:01:43.740 --> 00:01:47.580 align:start position:0%
 reproduce the faces of real artists
 using<00:01:44.136><c> artificial</c><00:01:44.862><c> intelligence</c><00:01:45.654><c>.</c><00:01:47.379><c> The</c>

00:01:47.580 --> 00:01:47.647 align:start position:0%
 using artificial intelligence. The
 

00:01:47.647 --> 00:01:49.726 align:start position:0%
 using artificial intelligence. The
 criticism<00:01:48.317><c> is</c><00:01:48.519><c> not</c><00:01:48.787><c> limited</c><00:01:49.323><c> to</c><00:01:49.524><c> the</c>

00:01:49.726 --> 00:01:49.793 align:start position:0%
 criticism is not limited to the
 

00:01:49.793 --> 00:01:52.341 align:start position:0%
 criticism is not limited to the
 appearance<00:01:50.530><c> of</c><00:01:50.731><c> the</c><00:01:51.000><c> characters</c><00:01:51.670><c>,</c><00:01:51.804><c> but</c><00:01:52.073><c> also</c>

00:01:52.341 --> 00:01:52.408 align:start position:0%
 appearance of the characters, but also
 

00:01:52.408 --> 00:01:54.822 align:start position:0%
 appearance of the characters, but also
 raises<00:01:52.877><c> questions</c><00:01:53.548><c> about</c><00:01:53.950><c> the</c><00:01:54.219><c> limits</c><00:01:54.688><c> of</c>

00:01:54.822 --> 00:01:54.889 align:start position:0%
 raises questions about the limits of
 

00:01:54.889 --> 00:01:57.236 align:start position:0%
 raises questions about the limits of
 using<00:01:55.291><c> images</c><00:01:55.761><c> and</c><00:01:56.029><c> facial</c><00:01:56.499><c> features</c><00:01:57.102><c> to</c>

00:01:57.236 --> 00:01:57.303 align:start position:0%
 using images and facial features to
 

00:01:57.303 --> 00:02:01.819 align:start position:0%
 using images and facial features to
 develop<00:01:57.840><c> virtual</c><00:01:58.376><c> idols</c><00:01:58.711><c>.</c><00:02:00.959><c> Netizens</c><00:02:01.604><c> are</c>

00:02:01.819 --> 00:02:01.891 align:start position:0%
 develop virtual idols. Netizens are
 

00:02:01.891 --> 00:02:04.545 align:start position:0%
 develop virtual idols. Netizens are
 questioning<00:02:02.752><c> whether</c><00:02:03.326><c> the</c><00:02:03.613><c> artists</c><00:02:04.187><c> whose</c>

00:02:04.545 --> 00:02:04.617 align:start position:0%
 questioning whether the artists whose
 

00:02:04.617 --> 00:02:07.056 align:start position:0%
 questioning whether the artists whose
 appearances<00:02:05.478><c> supposedly</c><00:02:06.267><c> served</c><00:02:06.769><c> as</c><00:02:06.984><c> a</c>

00:02:07.056 --> 00:02:07.128 align:start position:0%
 appearances supposedly served as a
 

00:02:07.128 --> 00:02:09.925 align:start position:0%
 appearances supposedly served as a
 reference<00:02:07.845><c> to</c><00:02:08.060><c> create</c><00:02:08.562><c> these</c><00:02:08.993><c> AI</c><00:02:09.208><c> idols</c><00:02:09.639><c> gave</c>

00:02:09.925 --> 00:02:09.997 align:start position:0%
 reference to create these AI idols gave
 

00:02:09.997 --> 00:02:12.508 align:start position:0%
 reference to create these AI idols gave
 their<00:02:10.428><c> consent</c><00:02:10.930><c>,</c><00:02:11.073><c> and</c><00:02:11.360><c> to</c><00:02:11.575><c> what</c><00:02:11.934><c> extent</c><00:02:12.436><c> a</c>

00:02:12.508 --> 00:02:12.580 align:start position:0%
 their consent, and to what extent a
 

00:02:12.580 --> 00:02:14.588 align:start position:0%
 their consent, and to what extent a
 company<00:02:13.154><c> can</c><00:02:13.440><c> be</c><00:02:13.656><c> inspired</c><00:02:14.301><c> by</c><00:02:14.517><c> a</c>

00:02:14.588 --> 00:02:14.660 align:start position:0%
 company can be inspired by a
 

00:02:14.660 --> 00:02:17.314 align:start position:0%
 company can be inspired by a
 celebrity's<00:02:15.521><c> image</c><00:02:15.951><c> without</c><00:02:16.525><c> crossing</c><00:02:17.171><c> an</c>

00:02:17.314 --> 00:02:17.386 align:start position:0%
 celebrity's image without crossing an
 

00:02:17.386 --> 00:02:21.065 align:start position:0%
 celebrity's image without crossing an
 ethical<00:02:17.960><c> line</c><00:02:18.247><c>.</c><00:02:19.659><c> Furthermore</c><00:02:20.303><c>,</c><00:02:20.420><c> MUO's</c><00:02:20.772><c> debut</c>

00:02:21.065 --> 00:02:21.123 align:start position:0%
 ethical line. Furthermore, MUO's debut
 

00:02:21.123 --> 00:02:23.291 align:start position:0%
 ethical line. Furthermore, MUO's debut
 has<00:02:21.357><c> reignited</c><00:02:21.943><c> the</c><00:02:22.178><c> debate</c><00:02:22.588><c> over</c><00:02:22.881><c> the</c><00:02:23.115><c> use</c>

00:02:23.291 --> 00:02:23.349 align:start position:0%
 has reignited the debate over the use
 

00:02:23.349 --> 00:02:25.459 align:start position:0%
 has reignited the debate over the use
 of<00:02:23.525><c> artificial</c><00:02:24.170><c> intelligence</c><00:02:24.931><c> in</c><00:02:25.107><c> K-pop</c><00:02:25.400><c>.</c>

00:02:25.459 --> 00:02:26.519 align:start position:0%
 of artificial intelligence in K-pop.
 

00:02:26.519 --> 00:02:28.506 align:start position:0%
 
 Many<00:02:26.829><c> fans</c><00:02:27.140><c> consider</c><00:02:27.699><c> it</c><00:02:27.885><c> unfair</c><00:02:28.320><c> for</c>

00:02:28.506 --> 00:02:28.568 align:start position:0%
 Many fans consider it unfair for
 

00:02:28.568 --> 00:02:30.928 align:start position:0%
 Many fans consider it unfair for
 companies<00:02:29.189><c> to</c><00:02:29.376><c> invest</c><00:02:29.810><c> in</c><00:02:29.997><c> virtual</c><00:02:30.494><c> artists</c>

00:02:30.928 --> 00:02:30.991 align:start position:0%
 companies to invest in virtual artists
 

00:02:30.991 --> 00:02:33.413 align:start position:0%
 companies to invest in virtual artists
 while<00:02:31.363><c> thousands</c><00:02:31.984><c> of</c><00:02:32.171><c> human</c><00:02:32.543><c> trainees</c><00:02:33.102><c> spend</c>

00:02:33.413 --> 00:02:33.475 align:start position:0%
 while thousands of human trainees spend
 

00:02:33.475 --> 00:02:35.897 align:start position:0%
 while thousands of human trainees spend
 years<00:02:33.848><c> training</c><00:02:34.407><c> without</c><00:02:34.904><c> getting</c><00:02:35.400><c> a</c><00:02:35.525><c> chance</c>

00:02:35.897 --> 00:02:35.959 align:start position:0%
 years training without getting a chance
 

00:02:35.959 --> 00:02:37.519 align:start position:0%
 years training without getting a chance
 to<00:02:36.146><c> debut</c><00:02:36.456><c>.</c>

