1
00:00:01,719 --> 00:00:03,582
The new boy group made by artificial

2
00:00:03,582 --> 00:00:03,634
The new boy group made by artificial

3
00:00:03,634 --> 00:00:05,549
The new boy group made by artificial
 intelligence that everyone is calling

4
00:00:05,549 --> 00:00:05,601
intelligence that everyone is calling

5
00:00:05,601 --> 00:00:07,257
intelligence that everyone is calling
 to be disbanded, or so it seems,

6
00:00:07,257 --> 00:00:07,309
to be disbanded, or so it seems,

7
00:00:07,309 --> 00:00:09,276
to be disbanded, or so it seems,
 because the group keeps increasing its

8
00:00:09,276 --> 00:00:09,328
because the group keeps increasing its

9
00:00:09,328 --> 00:00:13,741
because the group keeps increasing its
 followers on Instagram. MUO is sparking

10
00:00:13,741 --> 00:00:13,807
followers on Instagram. MUO is sparking

11
00:00:13,807 --> 00:00:16,296
followers on Instagram. MUO is sparking
 another heated controversy among K-pop

12
00:00:16,296 --> 00:00:16,362
another heated controversy among K-pop

13
00:00:16,362 --> 00:00:18,851
another heated controversy among K-pop
 fans after its members were accused of

14
00:00:18,851 --> 00:00:18,917
fans after its members were accused of

15
00:00:18,917 --> 00:00:23,368
fans after its members were accused of
 looking too much like real idols. On

16
00:00:23,368 --> 00:00:23,433
looking too much like real idols. On

17
00:00:23,433 --> 00:00:25,899
looking too much like real idols. On
 October 14, Stone Music introduced the

18
00:00:25,899 --> 00:00:25,964
October 14, Stone Music introduced the

19
00:00:25,964 --> 00:00:28,495
October 14, Stone Music introduced the
 five-member group's pre-release single,

20
00:00:28,495 --> 00:00:28,559
five-member group's pre-release single,

21
00:00:28,559 --> 00:00:31,025
five-member group's pre-release single,
 but attention quickly shifted to their

22
00:00:31,025 --> 00:00:31,090
but attention quickly shifted to their

23
00:00:31,090 --> 00:00:35,260
but attention quickly shifted to their
 virtual faces. On social media,

24
00:00:35,260 --> 00:00:35,325
virtual faces. On social media,

25
00:00:35,325 --> 00:00:37,537
virtual faces. On social media,
 numerous users began comparing the

26
00:00:37,537 --> 00:00:37,602
numerous users began comparing the

27
00:00:37,602 --> 00:00:39,685
numerous users began comparing the
 appearance of the MUO members to

28
00:00:39,685 --> 00:00:39,750
appearance of the MUO members to

29
00:00:39,750 --> 00:00:42,223
appearance of the MUO members to
 artists already known in the industry,

30
00:00:42,223 --> 00:00:42,288
artists already known in the industry,

31
00:00:42,288 --> 00:00:44,565
artists already known in the industry,
 questioning how the characters were

32
00:00:44,565 --> 00:00:44,630
questioning how the characters were

33
00:00:44,630 --> 00:00:46,648
questioning how the characters were
 designed and why they looked so

34
00:00:46,648 --> 00:00:46,713
designed and why they looked so

35
00:00:46,713 --> 00:00:51,134
designed and why they looked so
 familiar. Among the artists mentioned

36
00:00:51,134 --> 00:00:51,214
familiar. Among the artists mentioned

37
00:00:51,214 --> 00:00:54,247
familiar. Among the artists mentioned
 whose looks the MUO members supposedly

38
00:00:54,247 --> 00:00:54,327
whose looks the MUO members supposedly

39
00:00:54,327 --> 00:00:56,722
whose looks the MUO members supposedly
 stole are names like Dohun and

40
00:00:56,722 --> 00:00:56,802
stole are names like Dohun and

41
00:00:56,802 --> 00:00:59,516
stole are names like Dohun and
 Young-woo from TWS, Zhang Hao from

42
00:00:59,516 --> 00:00:59,596
Young-woo from TWS, Zhang Hao from

43
00:00:59,596 --> 00:01:02,709
Young-woo from TWS, Zhang Hao from
 ZEROBASEONE, and Sunoo from ENHYPEN, in

44
00:01:02,709 --> 00:01:02,789
ZEROBASEONE, and Sunoo from ENHYPEN, in

45
00:01:02,789 --> 00:01:05,663
ZEROBASEONE, and Sunoo from ENHYPEN, in
 addition to general comparisons with

46
00:01:05,663 --> 00:01:05,743
addition to general comparisons with

47
00:01:05,743 --> 00:01:09,685
addition to general comparisons with
 members of TXT and ENHYPEN. A visual

48
00:01:09,685 --> 00:01:09,758
members of TXT and ENHYPEN. A visual

49
00:01:09,758 --> 00:01:12,377
members of TXT and ENHYPEN. A visual
 comparison with soloist Lee Hwan-hee

50
00:01:12,377 --> 00:01:12,450
comparison with soloist Lee Hwan-hee

51
00:01:12,450 --> 00:01:16,533
comparison with soloist Lee Hwan-hee
 also circulated. For some netizens, the

52
00:01:16,533 --> 00:01:16,602
also circulated. For some netizens, the

53
00:01:16,602 --> 00:01:19,147
also circulated. For some netizens, the
 similarities are so evident that they

54
00:01:19,147 --> 00:01:19,216
similarities are so evident that they

55
00:01:19,216 --> 00:01:21,762
similarities are so evident that they
 claim they can quickly identify which

56
00:01:21,762 --> 00:01:21,830
claim they can quickly identify which

57
00:01:21,830 --> 00:01:24,513
claim they can quickly identify which
 artists the MUO members remind them of,

58
00:01:24,513 --> 00:01:24,582
artists the MUO members remind them of,

59
00:01:24,582 --> 00:01:27,128
artists the MUO members remind them of,
 fueling accusations that the group is

60
00:01:27,128 --> 00:01:27,196
fueling accusations that the group is

61
00:01:27,196 --> 00:01:29,811
fueling accusations that the group is
 taking advantage of the image of idols

62
00:01:29,811 --> 00:01:29,880
taking advantage of the image of idols

63
00:01:29,880 --> 00:01:32,494
taking advantage of the image of idols
 who already have a recognized identity

64
00:01:32,494 --> 00:01:32,563
who already have a recognized identity

65
00:01:32,563 --> 00:01:36,614
who already have a recognized identity
 within the industry. The controversy,

66
00:01:36,614 --> 00:01:36,680
within the industry. The controversy,

67
00:01:36,680 --> 00:01:38,792
within the industry. The controversy,
 of course, has led some users to

68
00:01:38,792 --> 00:01:38,858
of course, has led some users to

69
00:01:38,858 --> 00:01:41,299
of course, has led some users to
 describe the project as an attempt to

70
00:01:41,299 --> 00:01:41,365
describe the project as an attempt to

71
00:01:41,365 --> 00:01:43,674
describe the project as an attempt to
 reproduce the faces of real artists

72
00:01:43,674 --> 00:01:43,740
reproduce the faces of real artists

73
00:01:43,740 --> 00:01:47,580
reproduce the faces of real artists
 using artificial intelligence. The

74
00:01:47,580 --> 00:01:47,647
using artificial intelligence. The

75
00:01:47,647 --> 00:01:49,726
using artificial intelligence. The
 criticism is not limited to the

76
00:01:49,726 --> 00:01:49,793
criticism is not limited to the

77
00:01:49,793 --> 00:01:52,341
criticism is not limited to the
 appearance of the characters, but also

78
00:01:52,341 --> 00:01:52,408
appearance of the characters, but also

79
00:01:52,408 --> 00:01:54,822
appearance of the characters, but also
 raises questions about the limits of

80
00:01:54,822 --> 00:01:54,889
raises questions about the limits of

81
00:01:54,889 --> 00:01:57,236
raises questions about the limits of
 using images and facial features to

82
00:01:57,236 --> 00:01:57,303
using images and facial features to

83
00:01:57,303 --> 00:02:01,819
using images and facial features to
 develop virtual idols. Netizens are

84
00:02:01,819 --> 00:02:01,891
develop virtual idols. Netizens are

85
00:02:01,891 --> 00:02:04,545
develop virtual idols. Netizens are
 questioning whether the artists whose

86
00:02:04,545 --> 00:02:04,617
questioning whether the artists whose

87
00:02:04,617 --> 00:02:07,056
questioning whether the artists whose
 appearances supposedly served as a

88
00:02:07,056 --> 00:02:07,128
appearances supposedly served as a

89
00:02:07,128 --> 00:02:09,925
appearances supposedly served as a
 reference to create these AI idols gave

90
00:02:09,925 --> 00:02:09,997
reference to create these AI idols gave

91
00:02:09,997 --> 00:02:12,508
reference to create these AI idols gave
 their consent, and to what extent a

92
00:02:12,508 --> 00:02:12,580
their consent, and to what extent a

93
00:02:12,580 --> 00:02:14,588
their consent, and to what extent a
 company can be inspired by a

94
00:02:14,588 --> 00:02:14,660
company can be inspired by a

95
00:02:14,660 --> 00:02:17,314
company can be inspired by a
 celebrity's image without crossing an

96
00:02:17,314 --> 00:02:17,386
celebrity's image without crossing an

97
00:02:17,386 --> 00:02:21,065
celebrity's image without crossing an
 ethical line. Furthermore, MUO's debut

98
00:02:21,065 --> 00:02:21,123
ethical line. Furthermore, MUO's debut

99
00:02:21,123 --> 00:02:23,291
ethical line. Furthermore, MUO's debut
 has reignited the debate over the use

100
00:02:23,291 --> 00:02:23,349
has reignited the debate over the use

101
00:02:23,349 --> 00:02:25,459
has reignited the debate over the use
 of artificial intelligence in K-pop.

102
00:02:25,459 --> 00:02:26,519
of artificial intelligence in K-pop.

103
00:02:26,519 --> 00:02:28,506
Many fans consider it unfair for

104
00:02:28,506 --> 00:02:28,568
Many fans consider it unfair for

105
00:02:28,568 --> 00:02:30,928
Many fans consider it unfair for
 companies to invest in virtual artists

106
00:02:30,928 --> 00:02:30,991
companies to invest in virtual artists

107
00:02:30,991 --> 00:02:33,413
companies to invest in virtual artists
 while thousands of human trainees spend

108
00:02:33,413 --> 00:02:33,475
while thousands of human trainees spend

109
00:02:33,475 --> 00:02:35,897
while thousands of human trainees spend
 years training without getting a chance

110
00:02:35,897 --> 00:02:35,959
years training without getting a chance

111
00:02:35,959 --> 00:02:37,519
years training without getting a chance
 to debut.
