So, BTS went number one, Blackpink went number one, and K-pop demon hunters has basically taken over the entire country at this point. So, why does K-pop in America still feel like a giant series of exceptions rather than like an actual mainstream genre? I don't think K-pop is failing in America. I don't think that's the right conversation that we need to be having. I think K-pop is doing something that is way more interesting. It keeps producing massive American moments, but doesn't ever really really become like a fully fledged, fully realized American mainstream habit. And I think one of the biggest mistakes that people make in America when it comes to K-pop is confusing a breakthrough with a takeover, because those are not even close to the same thing. Now, I just want to be clear with you, right? I am not saying that K-pop is unpopular in the US. I am not saying that groups like Blackpink and BTS and similar groups have failed here. And I'm not saying that Americans just like reject all foreign language music. It's when you're at the level where random people who don't even really listen to you still know who you are. They're still aware of your name and your presence. And in the streaming era over the past say like 10, 15 or so years or whatever, like charts are so fragmented. A top 10 song does not necessarily equate to a household name or artist, right? Like we're living in a time where you can look at the Billboard Hot 100, like the top 10, and there could be so many songs on there that you've heard thousands and thousands of times because of TikTok and Instagram, but you couldn't name not one of those artists if you like had a gun to your head. And that's the gap that I really want to discuss in this video, right? It's the gap between massive moments and like real stable mainstream recognition. And once you define mainstream the way I do with like a household name, I think that's when the conversation around K-pop in America truly changes. Because at that point, the question isn't really like if K-pop can win here, because it already has. The question really is like what kind of winning are we really talking about? Hello, if you're new here, my name is Cedric, and on my channel I discuss pop music and pop culture, and today we are going to be having a very interesting conversation around whether or not I think that K-pop will ever truly be a main stream genre in America. We have had more than one K-pop artist break through the American market, right? Think BTS. Think Blackpink and a few of their members, right? Like Lisa has had a couple of big moments in America. Rosé had one of the biggest songs of the past year alone. Groups like Le Sserafim have performed at Coachella. And like I said before, K-pop demon hunters is like a worldwide phenomenon, right? Those are all real, and I am not denying that. But I really want to make a distinction that sounds small, but it actually changes the entire argument. K-pop being big in America or popular in America is not the same as K-pop being mainstream in America. K-pop absolutely has a massive footprint in the US, and I am not here to pretend otherwise. BTS alone have had multiple number one songs and number one albums in the US. Born Pink by Blackpink went number one on the Billboard 200. And like Le Sserafim has broken into the Hot 100 with Easy. Like those are real achievements, and they really do matter. But when I say mainstream, like I said before, I really mean household recognition. And K-pop in America often feels like it's huge inside fandom spaces, inside certain corners of the internet. You'll often see, you know, tour videos of like, you know, different Blackpink members or whatever when you're on TikTok or Twitter or whatever. They do produce headlines here and there. But even with all of that, I just find that K-pop as a whole is much less present in casual everyday conversations. And that's why it can feel very culturally loud without feeling like it's anywhere near close to the default. And I think the reason for that is the same thing that really makes feel so powerful in the first place. K-pop is incredibly good at intensity. The only problem though is that intensity and like widespread popularity are not the same thing. I think the cleanest way to explain the difference is this. K-pop is often times designed to turn people into committed fans, not just people who vaguely know a song, right? Basically, K-pop is really good at creating like intense fan attachment. It doesn't just give you a song, it gives you members, it gives you choreography, it gives you lore, fan interactions, anticipation around comebacks, and everything else. So, instead of becoming something that like the average American hears in passing and goes like, "Oh, I think I know that song." Like it's more of like a smaller group of people who are really really invested in it. That's why I think fans don't just like listen to K-pop. Like they live with it, they live through it. And to be clear, like that is a strength, that's not a weakness. But it does mean that it's asking for the average American listener to commit a bit more than they are typically used to committing. But if you do, it's like the more that you invest in K-pop and the artists, the the groups that you love, the more rewarding that it becomes over time. But the flip side is that if you are not already invested in a K-pop group or idols, then it feels at times kind of like homework. Like you're you've missed so much, and it would just take too much to get involved at this point. And that leads directly into what I think is one of the biggest barriers that K-pop music faces in America, and it's not like necessarily a language issue. The biggest barrier that K-pop faces is the American obsession with authenticity, or at the very least the performance of authenticity. With K-pop, you have so many things like fancams, dance practice videos, vlogs, fan signs, challenge videos, behind-the-scene clips, etc. And that's part of the magic, but unfortunately, it's also part of the barrier. Because in America, people don't just want polish. They want polish that still somehow feels spontaneous, personal, like in the moment, and just like like real. Now, that's not to say that I think American pop is like inherently more authentic than K-pop, right? But I do think that American pop is much better at hiding the machine behind everything. K-pop often wears the system on its sleeve. You have the training, the synchronization, the company architecture, and like the visual perfection. And to a K-pop fan, often times that really is like part of the excitement, right? But to a casual US listener, often times that can come off as like overly polished, overly like manufactured, or even a little fake at times. I'm just I'm not trying to be rude, I'm just being honest. I have literally, no joke, have heard people describe K-pop idols as at times looking like AI, because the presentation can just look that flawless. That doesn't mean the artists themselves are fake, it just means that the machine behind them is way more visible than it is in America. And often times, American audiences really reward music that feels like personally authored, like the person they're supporting wrote the songs themselves. They like stuff that feels more like emotionally direct, a little messy at times, and just like less controlled overall. And that authenticity issue often times gets even worse when we stop talking about say like one person, one artist, and we start talking about like five, seven, or even like nine people at once. Because America is not just like, you know, focused on like an authenticity culture, right? It really is focused on like a solo star culture. And that brings me to what I think is the second biggest barrier when it comes to authenticity, and it is group size. American pop absolutely has room for groups, right? We have had plenty of boy bands, say NSYNC, Backstreet Boys, One Direction. And plenty of girl groups, think Fifth Harmony, uh Cat's Eye, now Destiny's Child, or like Little Mix if you want to go across the pond a little bit. That was more for me, because Little Mix didn't really they didn't kill it in the US like I wish they did, but whatever. But the culture overall still most of the time centers around solo artists, individual artists. Having one pop star makes it so much easier to create a narrative story around that pop star, which then helps to drive sales for albums, tours, whatever, right? When you have one person, you have one voice, one face, one story, one breakup, one redemption arc, right? When you have a very large group, a casual viewer can almost immediately feel lost, right? One of my personal favorite K-pop groups is ITZY. It will always be ITZY. I love me some ITZY. And speaking to like a general idea, like when it comes to ITZY, my favorite is Yeji. Yeji is for whatever reason Yeji's visual speaks to me. The way that Yeji speaks and sings speaks to me. I don't hate the other members, but I have my bias, right? And the more people you have in a group, the more opportunities you have for a bias. But the larger that group gets, the harder it is to pinpoint what the overarching narrative is. That's why I think groups like Girls' Generation or TWICE will always have a bit of a harder time fully transitioning to like a mainstream act in the US just because of group size alone. I remember one of the first TWICE songs that I've ever come across was More & More. That song gives me so much life, right? But I remember like I found it, I got super excited, and then I went to one of my family members, and I showed them like, "I found this new song, it's so good." And they were like, "Wait, who's it by?" And I showed them a picture, and they were like, "Are you kidding?" And they started laughing. And I was like, "Ex- Why are you laughing? What are you What's What's so funny about this?" And they were like, "There are so many people. It looks like a classroom of people. Like why Why are there so many people in that group? That's ridiculous." That reaction was annoying and dismissive, but it really reveals a real barrier when it comes to the groups of that size. Some American viewers just don't know where to look, who to follow, or how like one individual person is going to stand out. I think K-pop fans understand that the point is the unit, it's the collective. But a casual American listener often times wants one person to imprint on. And I think that same issue shows up in the way that authenticity works, too, right? Because it's so much easier to build a parasocial bond with one person than it is with nine. It's It's unfortunate, but it's just the truth. And so K-pop already has to overcome the perception of everything being so manufactured, and it has to overcome the often times view of like group size. The language barrier acts less like a main barrier, and more of like just an added layer of friction on top of everything else. Most K-pop songs that I'm familiar with, like I would say 80% of the song is in Korean, but you'll have a couple of moments where, you know, they'll sprinkle in some English. Because honestly, if from what I understand, I thought it was always because like in Korea or Japan or China, the having a couple of English words here and there is seen as like cool here and there, right? And I think having some English words in the song makes it to where it's a bit more palatable for an American or English-speaking audience because like even if you're mumbling through the whole song, you can say the English word at the end of the sentence, right? You know. So, I don't think language is a huge reason as to why K-pop struggles in the US, but I do think that it's a factor. Like a massive K-pop fan is probably going to go through the song and like read translations of the lyrics, but a casual fan is not going to put in that amount of work. And if a casual person cannot immediately understand what you're saying or what point or emotion you're trying to get across, it's going to be harder for them to feel that much more emotionally invested in the song to then drive them to become a massive fan. Now, to be clear, that doesn't stop songs from hitting or becoming successful, it just makes the broader like widespread appeal of that song just a little bit harder. And I do think that Americans are accustomed to certain languages like Spanish, for example. Think like Despacito, you know, that song was massive here and and it being in Spanish didn't matter. It actually encouraged a lot of people to learn the Spanish portions of the song, right? But I do think that like even with that, Americans are more accustomed to hearing Spanish than they are Korean. So, that makes it a little tougher. So, just to be clear, like language is not a wall, but it does add just a little bit of friction to the conversation. And weirdly enough, like even when K-pop songs remove that barrier and just do songs in full English, often times that's still not enough. Because at that point, like another problem can show up cuz it then feels less like K-pop and more like you're just trying to like assimilate to whatever's going on over here. And like as a fan of K-pop, I know I don't want that. Which is exactly why I think sometimes labels misunderstand what success in America should even look like. To be honest with you, I'm not even a big BTS fan. Like there's a couple of songs that I like here and there, but I'm overall I'm more of a fan of girl groups than boy bands. They just speak to me more, the choreography speaks to me more. I I just I don't know, whatever. So, I really had to like dig deep to find out why they are such an exception when it comes to K-pop in America. I don't think the answer is that oh, they just make the best songs. Like I think that's just way too easy and way too simple of an answer. I think at least my hypothesis is that BTS have become so huge here because they feel personal. They had scale, obviously, but they also made fans feel like they were real people. Like genuinely build a history with them as individual people. And that matters a lot in America because again, like Americans are obsessed with perceived authenticity. BTS didn't just show up as a product imported into America, right? BTS really feels like it's a group made up of people that fans could really get to know, follow, and become fully emotionally invested in. They also benefited from the, you know, general appeal of boy bands to young girls, teens, you know, and if we know anything, we know that young girls and teens are some of the most dedicated fans you can have. That demographic is one of the most durable fan engines in like all of pop culture history. But even with that, like BTS being huge still does not automatically mean they are now mainstream. And that's the exact distinction that I think a lot of people unfortunately miss. An exception this strong, like a group that has become this successful, can start to make people think like all the floodgates have opened. Like K-pop is now part of the mainstream conversation and I just don't think that's the truth. BTS are the exception that proves the rule, but they aren't the exception that erases it. And I think Blackpink honestly are the perfect example of why or how one massive act is not equal to like a genre-wide breakthrough. Now, don't get me wrong. I love me some Blackpink. My personal bias? I think it might be Jennie even though I've been seeing Jennie in music videos like going off and then I see her live and I'm like, "Wait, where's that energy at? Like what?" But I still think I I love me some Jennie. I think a close second would be Lisa. Blackpink are massive in the US. They are like a huge deal in America and I want to be really fair about that. They have a massive audience here and they have definitely broken boundaries. Like they absolutely belong in this conversation. But to me, Blackpink in America so often like it feels more like an event more than it feels like a mainstream like daily habit. And that doesn't make them less successful, but it does make the shape of the success a little bit different. Like one of the coolest moments that I've had recently was I went to my parents' house one time and my nieces were there and they were singing Blackpink songs. And they were singing like early Lisa songs like um uh I don't need the the money or like love Lisa love me love Lisa love me. Like they were going off like with the choreo. Like I walked in and I was like, "Oh my gosh, this is the first time that I have heard someone sing Blackpink in my like daily life outside of like me and my best friend." It was just super cool cuz it felt like K-pop was slowly starting to kind of leak from just being a thing that I enjoy by myself in my headphones at the gym to something that's actually like leaking into the people in my daily life, you know? But if I ask a random person to just name five girl groups, for whatever reason I just don't think they're going to name Blackpink unless they are already kind of plugged in to K-pop or just like, you know, online pop culture. And this is exactly why I think that K-pop Demon Hunters is such a fascinating case study. Because I think it might might have cracked the code for how to package K-pop in a way that American audiences are able to digest faster. K-pop Demon Hunters has done something really interesting where basically they've made K-pop legible to Americans without asking Americans to like fully learn or understand the K-pop idol system first. I do think the movie is proof that Americans do like K-pop when it's done in a way that feels familiar. It really lowers the barrier of entry, right? Like you don't need years and years of K-pop idol knowledge to have access to it. The themes are universal, too. It's about hiding yourself, the shame, self-acceptance, finally embracing who you are, and actually being rewarded for that. And that's why I think this movie was able to grab audiences across age groups, not just, you know, K-pop fans. And so to me, the movie doesn't prove that, you know, we've solved the K-pop mainstream problem. It just proves to me that the appetite is there when the translation is strong. Does that make sense? And once you see that, then the next question becomes a little uncomfortable for the industry as a whole. If Americans seem to like K-pop when it's like softened, translated, or like reformatted, what happens when labels start trying to do that to actual like real-life groups? And that brings us to my last claim that like sometimes chasing the American audience and what you think the American audiences want can like water down or or flatten the very thing that makes K-pop so fun, unique, and special. I can't say for sure that labels are hurting K-pop artists by trying to, you know, make them more like American artists, but I can say that it happens often enough where it should be discussed. The more that some K-pop groups kind of lean into a more like a flatter American pop style, the less distinct the whole experience starts to feel. Sometimes that can mean that the core audience in Korea, Japan, and China start to like the music less. And even with that, like it's often times still not enough for American audiences anyway. And that creates this weird dynamic where it's like it's too watered down for the typical audience to enjoy, but it's also still too unfamiliar for the American audience you're trying to pull to enjoy it either. And this is part of the reason why before like I said before, why I when K-pop artists release like full English songs, I often don't listen to them because that's not why I'm here. I want the K-pop experience. If I wanted the American experience, there are already thousands and thousands of artists who are already trying to do that. And that's why I really don't think this situation is like as doom and gloom as you may think it is. I actually think this is like one of the most healthiest places that we can be in terms of this conversation. One of my favorite artists is Shakira. I love me some Shakira. I've been a Shakira fan since I was a child. And again, it's the same thing as with like K-pop songs. Shakira over her career has released a couple of songs like fully in English, and best believe I'm not listening to that. Do you know um Whenever, Wherever? In that song where she's like, "Lucky that my breasts are small and humble so you don't confuse them with mountains." It's like, what? Like yeah, you probably said something similar in Spanish, but it sounds so much better in Spanish. I don't want to hear that in English. >> [laughter] >> It's crazy that the irony here is that like K-pop feels more replaceable the more it tries to become like familiar to whatever's going on over here. I love everything about K-pop. The only thing that I would say that I have never been a huge fan of is that if sometimes this is obviously not like a blanket statement that could be, you know, applied to every single K-pop group or artist, but it often times feels like, you know, K-pop groups exist on like two sides of the extremes. Like the girl groups have to be like hyper-feminine, pink, bubbly, bright, fun, and then the boy groups have to be like super masculine and dominating and like their moves have to like, you know, like it really comes across like cuz like it's a huge thing in K-pop where members of different groups will come together and do like short-form video choreography of like the others' songs or whatever. And I've always noticed it like if a guy and a girl are doing a dance together and the guy is doing the dance from one of the girls' group's songs, he always has to make it like this butch um like, you know, and I'm just like, but like it's not like you can fem it up a little bit. That's why I love groups like X Love, one of my favorite groups right now because they are like breaking molds in a way that I just have not seen yet and it's just it's great. But I wonder if that just comes from like capitalism and the idea that like if male K-pop idols are shown to be like too feminine, then like they'll lose some of their female audience and vice versa and, you know, obviously labels want to make as much money as possible, so they don't want that. Which that seems like it makes a lot of sense, but I can't say that I know everything about the behind the scenes to say that that is exactly why it is, but I've always noticed that's I don't love that, I guess. So, no, I don't think K-pop will ever become as mainstream in the US as, say, American pop. But, the more that I think about it, the more that I don't see that as a loss. K-pop has already done the hard part. It proved that it can matter here. It can chart here, tour here, trend here, create strong fandoms here, and create moments that like the whole internet has to pay attention to. But, I still don't think it will ever reach the level of mainstream as some of our like legacy artists, like, say, Beyoncé, Gaga, or even like Justin Timberlake. And that's not because it's not like good enough or popular enough. I think that's just because the whole experience is built differently. And honestly, like, I don't even know if becoming mainstream in the US is even worth what K-pop would have to sacrifice to get there. Groups like BTS and Blackpink did not win here because they became, like, you know, pseudo-American acts. They won by becoming too big to ignore while still feeling like themselves. And to me, like, that's way more interesting than just becoming another act that's fighting for a spot on American radio. Now, if you disagree with any of my thoughts, please let me know. Comment down below what your thoughts are. I love having those comments with you guys. I got a question for you. Do you think that K-pop is mainstream in the US or do you kind of think, like I do, where it's not and you don't think it ever will be, but it does successfully create a lot of fun, exciting, massive cultural moments that, you know, cannot be replaced. Let me know what you think. I love you guys so much. Thanks for hanging out with me today. I appreciate it, and I will see you all in the next one.